For those of you who feel overwhelmed in making choices about wine at restaurants or at wine shops and supermarkets that have inordinately large selections, this blog is for you. Any restaurant with an enormous wine list (say 1000 labels or more) should have a sommelier on hand to guide your decision. Remember, a sommelier ultimately wants to sell you wine but also should ask some basic questions to help guide his recommendation.
First, the sommelier will probably ask what you are eating, or what type of event the wine is for (solo consumption, a dinner, a series of hors d’oeuvres, etc.). This will help to characterize the pairing. Usually sommeliers will go with traditional pairings: stronger wines with stronger foods, like-like combinations.
Second, the sommelier will likely ask how much money you had in mind to spend. The tendency here will be to push the price higher as most sommelier work on commission.
Third, they may ask if you have any specific preferences as to the qualities of the wine. Full-bodied, a specific varietal, etc.
Then they should make 3-4 recommendations and let you choose. Very rarely will they actually choose for you as this minimizes their risk. I find they tend to be much like lawyers in this way. Giving several options but not actually exercising their opinion on you.
And in a sense this is good because each sommelier also will have his or her own personal preferences. Some hate entire regions or varietals of wine. In a recent Food and Wine article, I read about several sommeliers who used very nasty language to describe Pinot Grigio, Chardonnay, and other respective varietals and one who condemned the entire Alsace region’s white wines. Thus, it is important to know the expert or critic who is giving wine advise. I even met a sommelier once who said he actually hates ALL wine except for muscat.
Why the heck is this guy a sommelier?