When to Send Back Flawed Wine in a Restuarant
No one means to become a wine snob, it just sort of happens. One day you wake up and find it hard to just enjoy a casual glass of wine with out analyzing it from a critic’s perspective.
The other day for lunch I ate a Chez Pauline in Recoletta. http://www.chezpauline.com.ar/
I was offered two options; Norton Classico blanco or tinto. http://www.norton.com.ar/ The same internal struggle stirred inside me again. I wanted a glass of wine, and ignored my conscience.
Yes, I have had the displeasure of drinking Norton before. And yes 10 pesos per cup seemed awfully high, possibly more than the cost of a bottle in the supermarket. But, I refused to let myself be snooty and decided to give it another go.
Norton Classico taste like stems and nail polish remover. Not even delicious boxed wine juice. Yet people like me still order it and drink it begrudgingly. I enjoyed my sandwich and after 2 sips left the glass stare me in the face for the rest of the meal. Filled to the brim and mocking me, “yes you should have ordered beer” I thought about a question someone asked during a tasting.
When ordering wine in a restaurant when is it acceptable to send it back?
Only if the wine is flawed.
If you chose a wine and did not like it, it is best to drink it but not order it again. Like my Norton which may be the worst wine in Argentina, shame on me for falling back into it’s tannic acidic trap. Each wine is an experience, and you won’t love everyone you try.
However if you suspect your wine is flawed consult your waiter or sommelier.
What do I mean by flawed or “corked”?
If a wine tastes “off” or damp, funky, moldy like wet socks, you probably received a corked bottle. It is not often that this occurs, but it does happen for many numbers of reasons; oxidation, sulphur, sediments etc. Check out this article on the Wine Doctors website for more information http://www.thewinedoctor.com/
In proper conduct the restaurant should take the bottle back and bring you another bottle of the same wine. Chances are the second bottle will not have the same error.
This goes for wine shops as well. Don’t pour that bottle down the drain. Take it back to the store you purchased it at and asked for a new bottle. Imagine going home like a carton of milk. Ready to enjoy cereal your pour and find sour curdled revulsion. Anyone would have just cause to return and ask for a replacement.
As I finished my meal and signaled for the check I saluted sir Norton for having tricked me again. He knew complaining about his corner cutting charms would only bring disappointment in another inherently disturbing glass.